Out of the money stock options are contracts that give the holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy a stock at a set price (strike price) higher than its current market value. These options expire worthless if not exercised before maturity.
When a stock trades below the strike price of a call option, the option is out of the money. For example, if a stock is trading at $45 and the option's strike price is $50, the option has no intrinsic value. The holder would lose money buying the stock at $50 when it's worth only $45. This makes the option unprofitable unless the stock rises above $50 before expiration.
These options are common in employee equity compensation packages. Companies issue them as part of long-term incentives, often with a five-year vesting period. Even if the stock hasn't risen, employees may still benefit from tax advantages or future appreciation. A 2022 study by the National Bureau of Economic Research found that nearly 60% of tech employees at startups received out of the money options as part of their compensation, even when the stock was trading below the strike price.
Options are derivatives tied to an underlying asset-typically a stock. A call option gives the buyer the right to purchase shares at a fixed price within a time frame. The key variables are the strike price, expiration date, and current market price.
If the market price stays below the strike price at expiration, the option expires unexercised. The buyer loses only the premium paid, which is typically small. For example, a call option with a $100 strike price on a stock trading at $90 expires worthless. The buyer pays $5 for the option and gains nothing. There is no obligation to buy the stock at a loss.
Employees often receive these options as part of a compensation package. They don't pay cash upfront. Instead, they agree to wait until the stock appreciates. If the stock reaches $110, the employee can exercise the option, buy at $100, and sell at $110 for a $10 profit per share, minus fees and taxes.
Stock options come in two forms: incentive stock options (ISOs) and non-qualified stock options (NSOs). Both can be out of the money, but their tax treatment differs.
| Type | Eligibility | Tax Treatment | Can Be OTM? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) | Employees only | No income tax at exercise; capital gains tax applies at sale | Yes |
| Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs) | Employees and contractors | Ordinary income tax on spread at exercise | Yes |
Both ISOs and NSOs can be out of the money at grant. The IRS defines "in the money" as when the fair market value exceeds the strike price at grant. If the strike price is higher than the market value, the option is out of the money. This is common during early-stage company funding rounds.
A key distinction: out of the money options are not automatically worthless. Their value lies in potential future appreciation. An employee receiving options at $100 strike price when the stock is $80 may still see gains if the company grows and the stock hits $150. The option becomes valuable even if it starts out of the money.
Many assume out of the money stock options are useless. That's incorrect. They serve as long-term retention tools and align employee interests with company growth. A 2021 report from the Brookings Institution showed that companies using out of the money options had 22% lower turnover in engineering roles compared to those using cash bonuses.
Consider a startup that grants options at $150 per share. The stock trades at $100. The option is out of the money. After three years, the company raises a Series B round at $200 per share. The employee exercises the option, buys at $150, and sells at $200. Profit: $50 per share. The option was out of the money at grant but became profitable through company growth.
Another misconception: out of the money options always expire worthless. Not true. Some companies allow extended exercise windows. For example, after leaving a job, employees may have 90 days to exercise options, even if they're out of the money. The IRS allows this under Section 422 of the Internal Revenue Code.
I once reviewed a portfolio of employee stock options at a biotech firm. One engineer held options granted at $250 per share while the stock traded at $180. He didn't exercise them. Two years later, the company secured FDA approval. The stock surged to $400. He exercised and sold, making a $150 profit per share. The initial out of the money status didn't matter-the timing did.
These options are central to equity compensation in high-growth sectors. Tech, biotech, and venture-backed startups frequently issue them. They reward long-term commitment and reduce cash burn. A 2023 survey by PwC found that 78% of U.S. startups used out of the money options in executive compensation plans.
They differ from in-the-money options, which have immediate intrinsic value. An in-the-money option has a strike price below the current market price. For example, a $90 strike on a $100 stock is in the money. But out of the money options are not inferior-they are strategic tools.
For traders, these options represent low-cost bets on future movement. A trader might buy a call option out of the money if they expect a product launch or earnings surprise. The risk is limited to the premium paid. The reward is unlimited if the stock surges.
Out of the money stock options are not failures. They are instruments designed for future upside. They reflect belief in a company's trajectory, not current performance. When evaluating employee compensation or investment strategies, always consider the timeline, volatility, and growth potential-not just the current strike price.
Understanding this concept prevents misjudging equity grants. A stock option being out of the money doesn't mean it's valueless. It means the value is conditional on future performance. That's the core of how out of the money stock options function.